 Research
 Open Access
 Published:
Theory and practice of micro wateroil displacement efficiency based on mathematical models
Journal of Mathematics in Industry volume 9, Article number: 4 (2019)
Abstract
Theoretical study about quantitative influence of the micro parameters (interfacial tension, wetting angle, distance, unit length, bottom radius, boundary distance, etc.) on the macro parameters (oil displacement efficiency, pressure gradient, etc.) in wateroil displacement process is very important. This paper focuses on the micro oil displacement efficiency calculation method in oil reservoir, building a new bridge between these parameters. Combining fluid motion equation, continuity equation to pressure gradient equation, the occurrence radius equation of remaining oil in different capillary is established; Taking mercury intrusion porosimetry experiment and constructing the mathematical model, new normal probability distribution of pore radius is achieved, and then a new probability function for injected water entering pore throat is established based on the occurrence radius equation and pore radius distribution equation; By using the Darcy’s Law and definite integral theory, new micro oil displacement efficiency equation is obtained. The Nuclear Magnetic Resonance experiments show: new method gets high calculating accuracy, and can be used to guide oil reservoir development.
Introduction
Experts and scholars focus on wateroil displacement efficiency for years. Richardson [1] shows the oil displacement efficiency in weak hydrophilic rock samples is higher than that in strong hydrophilic rock samples. And then, Morrow [2] find there is a negative correlation between the wateroil displacement efficiency and rock sample hydrophilic characteristics. Li [3] and He [4] study the Permeability influence on wateroil displacement efficiency in two different stages. Wang [5] gives the Positive correlation of feature value function and wateroil displacement efficiency. Cai [6] and Shen [7] and Chen [8] show the negative correlation of inhomogeneity of pore structure and wateroil displacement efficiency. Yu [9] studied the Oil and water viscosity ratio influence on wateroil displacement efficiency. Lu [10] studies the indication phenomenon is a key factor influence the oil displacement efficiency. Yan [11] gives that the wateroil displacement efficiency increased by Injection multiples. Jiao’s research [12] shows that the EOR is logarithmic to the injected pore volume. Fu [13] shows the replacement pressure is positive correlative to the oil displacement efficiency in the early development stage. Fan Li [14], Rogério Soares Silva [15], Zheng [16] and Dong [17] also work on how to improve the EOR. However, there is seldom theoretical research on micro factors influences (such as interfacial tension) on macro factors (oil displacement efficiency), and the explanation of oil field development phenomena is usually acted by our experiences.
In previous time, my team studied oil displacement efficiency from different aspects: based on the water flooding location, the water drive characteristic curve, the statistic methods ANN and \(GM(1,n)\) and the timevarying system [18,19,20,21,22,23,24]. After years’ study, we find there is a necessary quantitative connection between wateroil displacement efficiency and these micro factors. This manuscript aims to establish new relationships between macro parameter wateroil displacement efficiency, pressure gradient with the micro parameters interfacial tension, wetting angle, distance, unit length, bottom radius, boundary distance, etc. Then, we will get the interaction mechanism between the macro parameters and the micro parameters.
Remaining oil occurrence radius in capillary
For the incompressible singlephase liquid, the seepage process in a homogeneous reservoir is isothermal steady.
Fluid motion equation:
Continuity equation:
Combining Eq. (1) to Eq. (2), Eq. (3) is established:
For some particular reservoir with bottom water or lumpy oil layer, etc, the liquid flow in the bottom well is spherical directed flow.
Using space polar coordinate form in Eq. (3), Eq. (4) is established:
Combing Eq. (4) to Eq. (3) gives:
By solving Eq. (5) gives Eq. (6) and Eq. (7):
For any stratigraphic micro unit, \(\delta_{R}\) is the unit length, when the driving force in the place R is big enough to displace the crude oil in the pore throat, the Eq. (8) of pressure gradient is established:
The pressure gradient in any pore throat in place R and \(R + \delta_{R}\) equals to the overcoming resistance force, Eq. (9):
Combing Eq. (8) to Eq. (9) gives the maximum occurrence radius equation of remaining oil in different capillary, see Eq. (10):
Hence, the maximum occurrence radius changed by pressure gradient \(p_{e}  p_{w}\), wetting angle θ, the unit distance, the unit length \(\delta_{R}^{  1}\), the bottom radius \(r_{w}\), the boundary distance \(r_{e}\) and the interfacial tension σ.
For polymer flooding, the polymerized substance can change the wetting angle and interfacial tension, and then the occurrence radius changed. By increasing displacement PV, the \(r_{D}\) will also be changed, we can also quantitatively compare the difference of water drive and polymer flooding efficiency with parameter \(r_{D}\).
For heterogeneous oil reservoirs, the fluid motion equation and continuity equation will be changed, we can also use the abovementioned steps to obtain \(r_{D}\).
New oil displacement efficiency calculation method
The MIP experiment data show that the probability distribution of pore radius is normal. When using numerical fitting method, gives probability distribution equation of pore radius, Eq. (11):
For any capillary in the given unit length \(\delta_{R}\), the radius is \(r_{i}\), the pore volume is:
In the displacement process, the water first enters the large capillary pores, and then gradually enters the small capillary pores corresponding with the increase of pressure; for the imbibition process, the phenomenon is just reversed. Assume that the water can complete displace the oil in the capillary, and then we get the oil displacement efficiency \(E_{D1}(r_{D})\):
Where i counts from 1 to the number of capillary in the interval \([r_{D},r_{\max}]\), and j counts from 1 to the number of capillary in the interval \([r_{\min},r_{\max}]\).
Introducing definite integral theory to Eq. (13), gives
When fixing the unit length in any capillary, it is
Combing Eq. (11), Eq. (15) to Eq. (14) gives
However, not all of the injected water enters the capillary pores, the residual part, the discontinuous part and the possible formation pathway should be taken into consideration. In order to get the probability function for injected water entering pore throat, the fluid conductivity function \(\eta (r)\) should be established. According to the Poiseuille Law, the flow equation in single capillary can be established:
The fluid conductivity function in single capillary is achieved:
Hence, the probability function \(J_{k}(r_{D})\) is obtained
Hence, the oil displacement efficiency \(E_{D}\) can be calculated
Here, \(E_{D}(r_{D})\) is an error function, \(E_{D}(r_{D}) = \operatorname{erf}(r_{D})\), math softwareMatlab can be used to calculate the numerical solution.
Hence, \(E_{D}\) is a function of \(\Delta p,r_{w},r_{e},\sigma,\delta_{R},\theta\), it is
By introducing related reservoir engineering measurement to change related factors can lead to the change of \(E_{D}\).
Results and discussion
(1) PIM experiment and pore radius distribution. By analyzing lots of PIM experiment data, we find the distribution of pore radius follows the normal distribution, such as the data from GD742J195TG block of SL oilfield. The data figure between mercury saturation, accumulated permeability contribution values and pore radius is given, see Fig. 1.
By using the numerical fitting method, the normal distribution fitting equation is achieved, see Fig. 2:
(2) Calculation of oil displacement efficiency. The related parameter values in GD742J195TG block see Table 1.
By using Eq. (10) gives:
The Occurrence radius distribution curve in different places and pressure gradient can be achieved, see Fig. 3 and Fig. 4.
Assume that the displacement pressure gradient is 0.2 Mpa, and then parameter values are obtained: see Table 2, Fig. 5 and Fig. 6.
Figure 5 shows that the Percentage of water entries into rock pore decreased by occurrence radius, when the occurrence radius is small enough, the water can 100% enter the pore capillary.
Figure 6 shows: the oil displacement efficiency decreased by occurrence radius. When the occurrence radius is smaller than 25 μm, the oil displacement efficiency is over 80%, and when \(R=5\) m, \(r_{D} = 6.465\) μm, the oil displacement efficiency is near to 0.937788 in the GD742J195TG block. Hence, the oil displacement efficiency decreased by occurrence radius.
According to the definition of oil displacement efficiency, gives
When the displacing time and pressure gradient is big enough, the remaining oil saturation equals to the residual oil saturation, it is \(s_{\mathrm{or}} = s_{o}\), the oil displacement efficiency maximized.
Hence, the oil saturation in any place can be calculated
Here, statistics method is used to calculate the average oil saturation \(\overline{s_{o}}\)
Using Eq. (26) and data of Table 2, water saturation is achieved, \(s_{o} ( \Delta p = 0.2~\mathrm{Mpa} ) = 0.22744\).
By using the same method, the oil saturation in different displacement rate (0.05 mL/min; 0.5 mL/min; 2 mL/min) in different rock sampleA7, B9, C112 can be achieved, see Table 3.
(3) NMR experiment: verification and discussion. By carrying Out Nuclear Magnetic Resonance experiments and using rock samples A7, B9, C12, T2 distribution curve Fig. 7, Fig. 8 and Fig. 9 and MRI Fig. 10, Fig. 11 and Fig. 12, oil saturation Table 4 are obtained.
In Fig. 10, Fig. 11 and Fig. 12 the oil is red and the water is blue, separately. Figure 10, Fig. 11 and Fig. 12 show: the remaining oil saturation can be achieved and the residual mechanism can be concluded.
By analyzing the data in Table 3 and Table 4, Fig. 13 is obtained.
Figure 13 show that the theoretical calculating results of oil saturation is close to the experimental results. The oil saturation variance of sampleA7 is 2.116367, sampleB9 is 3.3992, and sampleC112 is 2.978333. Hence, new method can be used to guide the oilfield development.
Conclusions
(1) Occurrence radius of remaining oil is decided by pressure gradient, wetting angle, well distance, the unit length, the bottom radius, the boundary distance and the interfacial tension, influencing the oil displacement efficiency, it collects micro factors and macro factor in a special way.
(2) MIP experiments data show that the distribution of pore radius is normal, and the probability expression can be worked out by numerical fitting method, and it can be used to calculate pore radius distributions of new blocks in the same oil reservoir.
(3) Not all of the injected water enters the capillary pores, the residual part, the discontinuous part and the possible formation pathway should be taken into consideration.
(4) The micro oil displacement efficiency decreased by occurrence radius.
(5) NMR experiments can be used to test the accuracy of the new method, and the experiments data of rock samples A7, B9, C12 show: the NMR experiments values (oil saturations) are in accordance with the values calculated by new method.
Abbreviations
 MIP:

Mercury intrusion porosimetry
 NMR:

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance
 EOR:

Enhanced oil recovery
 v̅ :

Flow speed, ml/min
 K :

Permeability, \(\mu \mathrm{m}^{2}\)
 μ :

Viscosity, \(\mathrm{mpa} \cdot \mathrm{s}\)
 Δp :

Pressure gradient, Mpa
 ∇:

Nabla operator
 R :

Distance between the arbitrary point of formation and the production well, m
 \(r_{e}\) :

Distance between the formation border and the production well, m
 \(r_{w}\) :

Bottom radius, m
 \(p_{e}\) :

Border formation pressure, m
 \(p_{w}\) :

Bottom well pressure, m
 \(p_{R + \delta_{R}}\) :

Formation pressure in position \(R + \delta_{R},\mathrm{Mpa}\)
 \(p_{R}\) :

Formation pressure in position R, Mpa
 \(\delta_{R}\) :

Formation unit length, m
 σ :

Interfacial tension, \(\mathrm{N}/\mathrm{m}\)
 r :

Capillary radius, μm
 θ :

Wetting angle, ^{∘}
 \(r_{D}\) :

Occurrence radius of remaining oil in capillary, μm
 \(\phi (r)\) :

Probability distribution of pore radius
 \(r_{\max} \) :

Capillary radius maximum, μm
 \(r_{\min} \) :

Capillary radius minimum, μm
 R̅ :

Average capillary radius, μm
 \(\sigma_{R}\) :

Standard deviation of pore radius
 C :

Fitting coefficient of pore radius probability distribution
 \(V ( r_{i} )\) :

Capillary volume with radius \(r_{i}\), \(\mu\mathrm{m}^{3}\)
 \(r_{i}\) :

Capillary radius (ith), μm
 \(E_{D1}(r_{D})\) :

Displacement efficiency without considering the discontinuous characteristics, μm
 q :

Flow, \(\mathrm{cm}^{3} \cdot \min^{  1}\)
 L :

Capillary length, μm
 \(\eta (r,L)\) :

Fluid conductivity, \(\mathrm{ml} \cdot \min^{  1} \cdot \mathrm{Mpa}^{ 1}\)
 \(J(r_{D})\) :

Probable function for injection water entering capillary
 \(E_{D}(r_{D})\) :

Micro displacement efficiency considering the discontinuous characteristics, μm
 \(S_{\mathrm{or}}\) :

Micro residual oil saturation
 \(S_{\mathrm{wc}}\) :

Bound water saturation
 \(\overline{S_{o}}\) :

Average residual oil saturation
References
 1.
Jadhunandan PP, Morrow NR. Effect of wettability on waterflood recovery for crudeoil/brine/rock systems. SPE Reserv Eng. 1995;10(1):40–6.
 2.
Morrow NR. Wettability and its effect on oil recovery. J Pet Technol. 1990;24(12):1476–84.
 3.
Li P. Brief introduction to lowpermeability oilfield development. Petr Geol Oilfield Dev Daqing. 1997;03:36–40 (in Chinese).
 4.
He W, Yang Y et al.. Expertimental study on waterflooding in ultralow permeability reservoirs. Lithol Reserv. 2010;04:109–11 115 (in Chinese).
 5.
Wang Y, Ying B. Relationship between reservoir pore structure and displacement efficiency. Henan Petr. 1999;13(1):23–5 (in Chinese).
 6.
Cai Z. The study on the relationship between pore structure and displacement efficiency. Petr Explor Dev. 2000;06:45–9 (in Chinese).
 7.
Sheng P. Basic research on enhancing oil recovery of matured oil fields. China Basic Sci. 2003;02:39–42 (in Chinese).
 8.
Chen T, Lin F. Impact of salinity on warm waterbased mineable oil sands processing. Can J Chem Eng. 2017;95(2):181–9.
 9.
Yu Q. Drive curves and decline curves for water drive field. Petr Explor Dev. 1995;01:39–42 (in Chinese).
 10.
Lu W. A study on displacement characteristics of SZ361 oil field. China Offshore Oil and Gas (Geology). 2003;03:34–7 (in Chinese).
 11.
Yan Z. Discussion on prediction of waterflooding displacement efficiency with field production data. Pet Geol Recovery Effic. 2010;03:99–101 (in Chinese).
 12.
Long J. The research of S oilfield extra high water cut period to displacement characteristics affection. North East Petroleum University. 2014;20–28.
 13.
Fu X, Sun W. Study of microscopic oil–water displacement mechanism of lowpermeability reservoir. Xinjiang Petrol Geol. 2005;26(6):681–3.
 14.
Li F, Luo Y, Hu P, Yan X. Intrinsic viscosity, rheological property, and oil displacement of hydrophobically associating fluorinated polyacrylamide. J Appl Polym Sci 2016;134(14).
 15.
Soares Silva R, Lyra PRM et al. A higher resolution edgebased finite volume method for the simulation of the oil–water displacement in heterogeneous and anisotropic porous media using a modified IMPES method. Int J Numer Methods Fluids. 2016;82(12).
 16.
Zheng X, Mahabadi N. Effect of capillary and viscous force on CO_{2} saturation and invasion pattern in the microfluidic chip. J Geophys Res, Solid Earth. 2017;122(3).
 17.
Kang DH, Yun TS. Minimized capillary end effect during CO_{2} displacement in 2d micromodel by manipulating capillary pressure at the outlet boundary in lattice Boltzmann method. Water Resour Res. 2018;54(6):895–915.
 18.
Liu HH. Study on remaining oil droplet dynamic conditions and water flood efficiency changing mechanisms in the ultrahigh water cut period. Southwest Petroleum University. 2013;9–11 (in Chinese).
 19.
Liu HH. Modified theoretical expression of water saturation in oil–water fluid flow area. Open Petrol Eng J. 2013;6(1):76–8.
 20.
Yue P, Xie Z, Huang S, Liang S, Chen X. The application of N2 huff and puff for IOR in fracturevuggy carbonate reservoir. Fuel. 2018;234:1507–17.
 21.
Liu ZB, Liu HH. An effective method to predict oil recovery in high water cut stage. J Hydrodyn, B. 2016;27(6):988–95.
 22.
Yue P, Xie Z, Liu H, Chen X, Guo Z. Application of water injection curves for the dynamic analysis of fracturedvuggy carbonate reservoirs. J Pet Sci Eng. 2018;169:220–9.
 23.
Yue P, Chen X, Liu H, Jia H. The critical parameters of a horizontal well influenced by a semipermeable barrier considering thickness in a bottom water reservoir. J Pet Sci Eng. 2015;129:88–96.
 24.
Liu ZB, Liu HH. Multifactors prediction of water flooding efficiency based on timevarying system. Commun Stat, Theory Methods. 2016;45(20):5873–83.
Acknowledgements
I always acknowledge reviewers and the associate editor and the support of Scientific Project of the Scientific Project of the vocational colleges teaching steering committee in ministry of education of China, No. 2018GGJCKT200 and the scientific project of Sichuan science and technology department, No. 2018CC0109.
Availability of data and materials
Fig. 1 in Sect. 3 is based on the MIP experiment data of SL oilfield in China (the initial data figure). Figure 6, Fig. 7 and Fig. 8 are MRI of samples of A7, B9 and C112 in different flow speed in SL oilfield (the initial data figure). Data sharing not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analyzed during the current study.
Authors’ information
Haohan Liu (198508), Ph.D. of oil and gas development engineering, vice professor, postdoctor, engaged in oil and gas development for 8 years, interested in optimization and statistics theory and application.
Funding
Here, I offer my regards and blessings to the Scientific Project of the vocational colleges teaching steering committee in ministry of education of China and the and the scientific project of education department of Sichuan Province, helping me taking the MIP experiment and collecting the initial data here.
Author information
Affiliations
Contributions
The main idea of this paper was proposed by HL, and the author prepared the manuscript initially and performed all the steps of the proofs in this research. The author read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Correspondence to Haohan Liu.
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
I declare that there is no competing interest.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Received
Accepted
Published
DOI
Keywords
 Occurrence radius
 Probability function
 Definite integral theory
 Oil displacement efficiency
 Nuclear Magnetic Resonance experiment